Boxcar Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Boxcar Pizza offers a delightful menu that stands out in Garrett, Indiana. Known for its Chicago-style deep dish pizza, this restaurant features a variety of specialty options like Chicken Bacon Ranch, All About The Meat, and the unique Big Mac pizza. The average price for standard pizzas is around $14.50, while specialty pizzas hover around $26.22. With an impressive selection of 50 dishes, including sides and grinders, there's something for everyone. Whether indulging in Crazy Dough or a large chef salad, diners find comfort in generous portion sizes and delicious flavors.

Boxcar Pizza Menu image 1

Featured Dishes

Taco Pizza
Taco Pizza
Meat Pizza
Meat Pizza
Garlic Naan
Garlic Naan
Boxcar Pizza

Boxcar Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

The interior of Boxcar Pizza offers a casual and inviting atmosphere. Warm colors and quirky artwork create a cozy vibe, perfect for family gatherings or casual hangouts with friends. The openness of the dining area echoes laughter and conversation, enhancing the community spirit. The focus remains firmly on the food, with a menu that appeals to diverse palates, ensuring every diner feels at home. Cleanliness is a priority, providing peace of mind as the tantalizing aromas fill the space, making it impossible not to feel hungry.

Boxcar Pizza

About Boxcar Pizza Food and Specialties

Boxcar Pizza takes pride in its eclectic menu, emphasizing creativity and quality in each dish. The Chicago-style deep dish pizza features a flaky crust that holds layers of gooey cheese and rich toppings. For those craving something different, options like the Pulled Pork Nachos and Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza surprise and delight. Each item blends flavors and textures, catering to the tastes of a diverse clientele. Regulars rave about the cleanliness and overall dining experience, which enhances the enjoyment of every meal. From cheese pizza to the adventurous 'Let's Go To Hawaii', every bite is memorable.

Boxcar Pizza

Boxcar Pizza is firmly committed to delivering exceptional food and service, making it a beloved staple in Garrett. The focus on quality ingredients and creative recipes ensures that every pizza is a delightful experience. Specialties like the Big Mac pizza and Chicken Bacon Ranch highlight the restaurant's dedication to innovation while honoring classic favorites. Each dish reflects a careful balance between taste and presentation, compelling diners to capture and share their meals on social media.

The vision for Boxcar Pizza extends beyond just serving delicious food; it aims to be a community hub where friends and families come together.

By engaging in local events and supporting nearby causes, it builds relationships that enhance its presence in Garrett. This commitment to community involvement underlines the ethos of Boxcar Pizza, where every slice tells a story of shared moments and joyful gatherings.