Boxcar Pizza

Discover delicious Chicago-style deep dish and creative pizza options at Boxcar Pizza in Garrett, IN. Enjoy generous portions, crazy dough, and a clean, welcoming atmosphere. Call +1 260-357-6666 today!

Welcome to Boxcar Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Boxcar Pizza
Boxcar Pizza
Boxcar Pizza
Boxcar Pizza

Boxcar Pizza is a delightful pizza restaurant located at 105 N Randolph St in Garrett, Indiana, known for its comforting atmosphere and delicious offerings. The moment you step inside, you're greeted with the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizzas and the warm, welcoming smiles of the staff. This joint is not just a place to eat; it’s a destination for families and friends gathering over unforgettable meals. It boasts an impressive menu featuring Chicago-style deep dish and creative specialty pizzas such as the Chicken Bacon Ranch and the Big Mac pizza. Each dish showcases generous portions and quality ingredients, ensuring satisfaction with every bite.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

105 N Randolph St, Garrett, IN 46738, United States

Phone

+1 260-357-6666

About

The Culinary Story

Boxcar Pizza
Boxcar Pizza
Boxcar Pizza
Boxcar Pizza

Boxcar Pizza embodies the spirit of comfort food while incorporating a creative twist that makes it stand out. The pizzeria offers a robust menu with over 50 items, catering to all types of diners, from meat lovers to vegans. With an average price of $15.36, it provides significant value, especially considering the quality and portion size. Popular options include the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza, combining tasty chicken and crunchy bits of bacon with a perfect blend of ranch dressing. However, the real star is their Chicago-style deep dish pizza, served with thick crusts and generous toppings that genuinely satisfy hungry appetites.

The menu further expands with delectable sides such as Crazy Dough and BBQ Sauce Cups, perfect for complementing your pizza experience.

For those looking for lighter fare, Boxcar Pizza offers a selection of salads that maintain freshness with every bite. The Grinders category features items like the Classic Ham & Cheese and The Subway Assassin, ensuring diverse options for all tastes.

Boxcar Pizza prides itself on its commitment to community engagement, participating in local events and fostering connections among Garrett’s residents. With its blend of delicious food and a friendly atmosphere, Boxcar Pizza has made a name for itself as the go-to pizza spot in town, where everyone feels invited to share a meal.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-8 PM
  • Monday4-8 PM
  • Tuesday4-8 PM
  • Wednesday4-8 PM
  • Thursday4-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-10 PM

Boxcar Pizza features a diverse range of mouthwatering pizzas, specialty flavors, and satisfying sides. Diners can choose from three distinct categories of pizza, including classic rolls, specialty options, and customizable creations. The standout dishes include the Chicago-style deep dish, renowned for its rich flavors and hearty toppings. The dessert isn't neglected here, either; the Crazy Dough and Crazy Sticks are fan favorites that add a unique twist. Cleanliness and attentive service rank highly among patrons, creating a wholesome dining experience. Boxcar Pizza ensures that the ambiance aligns with its delicious menu, providing a cozy space for enjoying meals with loved ones. I count the community involvement, where local events often feature this beloved eatery, bringing everyone together in celebration.

Boxcar Pizza

Boxcar Pizza greets visitors with a charming exterior that reflects its informal and inviting vibe. Situated on Randolph Street, the restaurant features a well-maintained façade that draws the eye while encouraging passersby to stop in for a slice. Outdoor seating options allow guests to enjoy their meals al fresco style during pleasant weather, emphasizing a laid-back, communal atmosphere.

Inside, the décor complements the pizza theme, filled with playful art and pizza-inspired decorations that celebrate the culinary craft. The casual setting invites everyone from families to friends to gather and enjoy good food without any pretentiousness.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

great pizza, great service! sausage was HUGE and loaded FULL of toppings!! yummy!!

C
Carlee R.

A cozy restaurant filled with tasteful memorabilia of the trains of old. Got the Mic pizza, a pizza similar in taste and flavor with a big Mac. Delightful and portioned well for the price. Will definitely support this business going forward. A must revisit to try their Chicago style pizza next.

Z
Zachary P.

Had the supreme pizza today. Picked up. I have to say it was hot and I ofctge best pizzas we've ever had. Worth every penny

b
beverly g.

I ordered a Chicago style 2 topping from here, and it was great. Compared to Timmy's, it is more expensive, but much heftier. Three slices from Timmys and I am full. I barely got 2 slices before I was done. Highly recommend!

R
Ryan C.

We got the chicken bacon ranch deep dish pizza and it was amazing! The staff was very friendly!

K
Kyle M.

Pizza is amazing, and a nice little place to dine in. Very friendly staff. Will definitely be back for more!

n
nathan b.